I think the title this week is ironic. I don’t know based on our known history of these characters that any one of them will have a happily ever after – except maybe Rose and Bernard. Things look good as of the end of this week for Desmond and Penny but I’m very skeptical if it’s going to turn out where they can sail off into the sunset.
1. Typical opening scene with Desmond’s eye. I can’t help but think back to Jacob’s cabin a few seasons ago when the eye appeared and freaked out Hurley. Whose eye was that? I’m not saying it’s Desmond’s eye but knowing that he can manipulate time and space then why couldn’t it be? It could also be that at the time 4 X 01 was filmed they didn’t have Jacob and MIB cast so they just used “someone” but it’s far more fun to speculate.
click to enlarge
2. If the generator hasn’t run for 20 years then does that mean they’ve been preparing all these years for this moment? What else could they have needed this large of a generator for?
3. Call me crazy but this sure does resemble the inside of Jacob’s cabin. Insert a crazy dog painting and there you go. Could Jacob’s cabin have been more than just a place for Jacob to sit and wait on Ben to come for orders? Could it have been some kind of portal between time lines?
click to enlarge
4. Maybe they should have drug the fried dead guy out of the cabin before bringing in Desmond. Might have not been such a scene that way.
5. How does Widmore know that Des survived an electromagnetic blast? Technically a lot of people, including Charlie, survived when Des turned the key. But someone from the island got word to Widmore about the blast. Also, this “test” that Widmore does this week is not the blast that he needs Desmond to survive and is not what he needs Des for yet. They still need to channel the energy from the pockets on the island. Maybe Des is going to be the conductor to the MIB and that is why is so OK going with Sayid.
6. I don’t think we’ve seen what Des is going to have to sacrifice but I’m guessing that it’s his life in one of the two time lines. Widmore showed him that he will have Penny either way so he can die in one and still have her in the other.
7. OK, so they are using electromagnetic energy on Des so he can mind travel. But I still think he’s got more work to do with this energy and that this experiment was just to set events in motion. I like the “flux” gauge the best.
click to enlarge
8. This show has had some pretty weak special effects but I thought they did a good job with this one. Des almost looked like he was in a “Honey, I Shrunk the Kids” scene though.
click to enlarge
9. Also, right after Des gets “lit up” the screen goes white then to the clouds. This all reminded me of Juliet hitting the bomb, flash to white then start this season in the clouds.
10. SKID, you are right. Two Desmond reflections. I would guess that yes, it’s of major significance.
click to enlarge
11. So many things about the Losties lives are the same in both timelines and it brought them aboard flight 815 even down to the outfits that they have on. Yes, there are some major differences in their lives (Saywer and his job, Jack having a son) but many things are the same. In the original timeline Desmond was not on board the flight because he was already on the island. There are many, many differences in Desmond’s life. In science experiments you throw in variables to see what the difference in the outcome will be. I would say that whether it be Jacob, MIB or Widmore playing this game, Desmond is for sure a variable on the board. His choices, his fate affect the direction of all of their lives.
12. Desmond reflecting on things that could have been, or were, or might still happen.
click to enlarge
13. Widmore tells Desmond that unless he can get Drive Shaft to the charity even that his wife (Eloise) will “destroy” him. Nice wording. Probably literal.
14. Desmond is finally worthy of Widmore’s MacCutcheon whiskey. Widmore needs him now whereas before Desmond didn’t appear to be on the right path. Maybe previously Widmore thought Des wasn’t “ready” and in this time line it’s Eloise that thinks he’s not ready/
click to enlarge
15. I’m sure we will look back on this painting and it will mean more by The End. For now I’m guessing it’s a wish for the scales to balance again. I’m going to firmly take sides and speculate that MIB is free in the new timeline. Widmore needs to use Desmond to balance the scales which does make him a good guy. Maybe he was a good guy in the original too. I still think that him wanting to kill Ben was to stop Ben from killing Jacob.
click to enlarge
16. How cool was it to see Desmond and Charlie back together again? They were having drinks again just like they did by the campfire.
click to enlarge
17. There is something very surreal about Charlie in the new timeline. When they go in the water while Desmond is struggling to get out Charlie just closes his eyes and succumbs to his fate. When they are the in the hospital he runs to be free and tells Desmond that there is nothing that they can do for him there. Why? I don’t think the guy is suicidal and there is something very special about him here.
18. Not Penny’s Boat. How does Charlie know to lift up his hand? But the doctor says Des bumped his head and it appears from Sun’s experience that you can cross over when you bump your head.
click to enlarge
19. And why aren’t these people on shore helping? Why not throw over a life preserver or something?
click to enlarge
20. The guy with Des at the MRI tells him to try and not press the button because then he’ll have to start all over from the beginning. Ironic, don’t you think?
21. OK, there is no way that the MRI machine sounding like Smokey is just a coincidence. And Smokey also “reads” people like the machine does (like when Smokey comes, Desmond is having flashes of his past/other life). Not that Smokey is an MRI machine but it’s still pretty ironic.
22. Gratuitous Charlie screenshot. I don’t know if we will get anymore for the remainder of the show so I just had to get one more in here. I love his character and thought it was fabulous to see him again.
click to enlarge
23. Eloise does not look very happy to see Desmond. While everyone else is finding their happily ever after mates something tells me that Eloise and Widmore aren’t the happiest married couple. Widmore has his agenda moving forward and she doesn’t seem to agree by trying to stop Des from finding out who Penny is. And SKID you are right again, the same symbol that Juliet had branded on her. I’m leaning towards Eloise being on the “black” side of the scale.
click to enlarge
24. I think that Eloise wants to stop Desmond because she does not want him to interfere with this timeline. My guess is that she probably made a deal with MIB to have her son back and doesn’t want Des to interfere with that. Remember that MIB does try to deal to bring back dead people (Nadia, Richard’s wife). She probably helped to free MIB in this time line in exchange for her son (Dan). She reminds Desmond that he has the “perfect life” including the thing that he wanted the most, Widmore’s approval. That was true for the old time line as well.
25. Another list. Eloise tells Des that he’s not ready to see the list. Who knows how many Losties are on that list. By the time he leaves the stadium, however, he is ready for the list and asks for a different one, the flight manifest.
26. Two dead people from the island and both reflections are black. Mankowski and Dan.
click to enlarge
27. I’m thinking that the “museum” is special. We know that Pierre Chang and Charlotte work there. Eloise has a connection (the fundraiser is there) and Dan hangs out there. I would guess we are going to see more Dharma connections come along at the museum this season. Maybe the new lighthouse station is there.
28. Why would Dan pull Des aside to talk about Charlotte and his crazy dream? Could it be because Dan wrote more than just one page of crazy equations? Maybe the page is in there where Dan wrote that Desmond Hume is his constant? Seems that Dan’s mind crossed over in his dream after being “sparked” by seeing Charlotte and that is how he remembered some of his physics.
29. Yes, Dan is a musician but his book was left behind in 1977. You can believe that Eloise and Dharma got their hands on that book and is probably how they know so much about time travel, Desmond, and the alternate time line.
30. I also wanted to get a gratuitous shot of Dan in here. He’s another one of my favorite characters and we might not see him again this season. Oh and yes, of course he’s wearing the tie! Now they need to bring in Juliet!
click to enlarge
31. OK, did Dan tell us that this new timeline wasn’t supposed to be an that maybe the energy needs to be released to end it? He speculates to Des that maybe “this” isn’t the life they were supposed to live. He may very well have to kill off all of the Losties in one time line or another to set things straight and it sounds like from Dan’s speech that the new time line has to go.
32. Anyone expecting Desmond to tell Penny, “See you in another life, brother sister” at the stadium?
33. Des wakes up on the island and is ready to go with Widmore’s plan. I think it’s part because he knows he will still be with Penny and part because he’s working for Widmore and gained what he wanted, his respect. There is a remote possibility that Des’s consciousness switched places between the two timelines so that the Des that didn’t have Penny can continue without her (on the island) and the Des that loves her now has her again in the new time line.
34. Did anyone else chuckle when Sayid just killed two people yet told Des that “these people are extremely dangerous?”
35. The fact that Sayid doesn’t kill Liz Lemon Zoe shows that he still has a little humanity left in him. There is good and bad in everyone.
36. What could Penny be training for when she’s running these stairs? Could it be for a sailboat trip around the world?
37. Is Des going to show the Losties through love that they have another life on the island? What about those who didn’t have it? Is he going to show him the way back to that love so that if he has to kill them all here they will understand or agree to go? Locke had to find a way to convince them to all go back, maybe Des does too.